Abstract
Enslaved children were a pervasive presence in the social world of Late Antiquity, yet they are remarkably difficult to recover from the surviving sources. They appear in sermons, letters, theological treatises and legal discussions, but almost never as subjects whose own experiences matter. This article examines that problem by asking how enslaved children were alienated not only socially, through slavery itself, but also within the literary and theological discourses that claimed to speak about them. Its central argument is that enslaved children in early Christian sources are “twice estranged”: first from family, ancestry and community, and secondly from their own histories when Christian writers transform them into rhetorical symbols of adult vice, virtue and social disorder.
The first form of estrangement draws on Orlando Patterson’s influential description of slavery as a condition of “social death”, particularly his concept of natal alienation. Enslavement did more than physically separate people from family members. It deprived enslaved persons of socially and legally recognised claims to ancestry, kinship and descendants. For children, however, this alienation was especially severe. Childhood itself depends fundamentally on relationships of care, kinship, dependency and social recognition. A child separated from parents and community therefore loses not simply relationships already formed, but the very social framework within which identity, belonging and status are meant to develop. For a freeborn child, family could also provide the witnesses, documentation and social memory necessary to prove free status. The destruction of those connections could consequently make enslavement practically irreversible.
Even identifying enslaved children in ancient texts is difficult because the vocabulary of childhood and slavery overlaps. Greek terms such as pais and paidiskē, and Latin puer and puella, could refer either to children or to enslaved persons, sometimes irrespective of age. This linguistic ambiguity reflects a broader social reality. Free poor children could work under conditions resembling those of enslaved children, while the boundaries between slavery, dependency, apprenticeship, debt and parental authority were not always clear. Language therefore did not simply describe an already stable social order; it helped naturalise a world in which childhood dependence and servile dependence could easily be associated with one another.
Early Christian preaching provides some of the most vivid descriptions of the sale of children. Basil of Caesarea, for example, imagines a destitute father during famine contemplating which of his children he should sell for food. Ambrose of Milan employs an almost identical scene. The emotional force of these passages lies in the destruction of the parent-child bond: the father sees his own likeness and future embodied in his children, yet hunger forces him to turn them into commodities. Such passages offer a powerful representation of the familial devastation produced by enslavement.
Yet their purpose is not primarily to condemn child slavery. The suffering child functions instead as evidence of some adult moral failure. For Basil, the scene exposes the consequences of greed and economic inequality. For Ambrose, the sale of children becomes an indictment of luxury, debt and usury. Jerome can go still further, interpreting the biblical image of boys and girls being exchanged for sexual pleasure and wine allegorically as a condemnation of corrupt ecclesiastical leaders. The child remains rhetorically powerful precisely because the child’s suffering can make another moral argument more shocking.
This is the article’s second form of alienation: literary or discursive estrangement. The child becomes highly visible in the text, but not as a historical subject. Enslaved children become instruments through which adult Christians are instructed about wealth, charity, episcopal responsibility, justice and sin. We consequently learn a great deal about the moral anxieties of bishops and preachers, but very little about the everyday worlds of enslaved boys and girls: their work, punishment, relationships, religious formation, emotional lives or strategies of survival.
The selectivity of early Christian compassion becomes even clearer in accounts of kidnapping and wrongful enslavement. Augustine describes slave traders operating in North Africa who abducted free persons and sold them overseas. Churches sometimes intervened dramatically to free such captives. Theodoret recounts the story of Maria, a freeborn North African girl of elite background who was captured and sold after the Vandal conquest of Carthage. Money was raised to redeem her, and she was eventually reunited with her father. Her enslaved female attendant, who was captured with her, simply disappears from the narrative. Similarly, Victor of Vita praises Bishop Deogratias for selling church treasures to ransom captives and reunite freeborn children with their parents.
The distinction is crucial. Christian outrage is repeatedly directed at the wrongful enslavement of those who ought to have been free, rather than at the enslavement of children as such. Freeborn children who had crossed the boundary into slavery became objects of sympathy and intervention. Children already regarded as legitimately enslaved largely remained outside the field of Christian compassion. The sources therefore establish what might be called a threshold of moral visibility: above it stands the freeborn child whose enslavement constitutes a scandal; below it stands the enslaved child whose condition is simply accepted.
Basil of Caesarea provides the article’s most striking test case. In his preaching on famine, Basil constructs intense pathos around the father forced to sell a beloved child. Yet in On the Holy Spirit he offers a radically different account of the enslavement of children. Some children, he states, are so lacking in judgement that it is actually beneficial for them to become the property of wiser and better persons. Their enslavement may therefore be understood not as a curse but as an act of providential ordering. Basil compares such persons to a chariot requiring a driver or a ship requiring a helmsman: the enslaved person supposedly receives from the master the rational direction that he or she lacks.
The contradiction is illuminating. Basil can regard the enslavement of one child as a profound violation of natural familial bonds while presenting the enslavement of another as beneficial. The decisive difference is not simply literary genre. It is the perceived status and value of the child. Compassion attaches itself to the threatened freeborn child, whereas the supposedly inferior child can be excluded from compassion altogether.
Basil’s reasoning is strengthened through his appeal to the biblical tradition surrounding Genesis 9 and the curse associated with Ham and Canaan. Within this interpretative framework, enslavement becomes connected to inherited guilt and divine providence. The social alienation of enslaved children can thus acquire theological legitimacy: servitude appears not as the consequence of human violence or exploitation, but as an appropriate destiny. The child is estranged not only from family and community, but also from the category of innocent victim.
The article therefore calls for a more explicitly child-centred historiography of ancient slavery. Christian literary texts remain indispensable, but their rhetorical visibility cannot simply be equated with social reality. Sermons and theological writings should be read alongside papyri, contracts, legal sources, inscriptions and material evidence that preserve different kinds of information about enslaved children: ages, prices, labour, household arrangements and relationships. Such cross-checking makes it possible to read Christian texts both for what they say and for what they systematically leave unsaid.
Recovering enslaved children from antiquity ultimately requires historians to resist reproducing the priorities of their sources. Early Christian writings did not merely record which children were visible; they participated in deciding whose suffering counted. A child-centred history must therefore look beyond the dramatic child placed at the centre of a sermon and ask about the many enslaved children who remained at its margins. Only then can the enslaved child move from being a rhetorical sign of someone else’s morality towards becoming a historical subject in his or her own right.
Keywords: Ambrose; Augustine; avarice; Basil of Caesarea; child slavery; childhood in antiquity; discourse analysis; early Christianity; historiography; kidnapping; natal alienation; rhetoric; social death
- This article’s featured image was created by Ali Akdemir and obtained from Pexels.
Lees die volledige artikel in Afrikaans

